[18+ Board] - [YP Home] - [Project Status] - [YP Wiki] - [Burichan] [Futaba] [Gurochan] [Photon] - [Home] [Manage]

[Return]
Posting mode: Reply
Leave these fields empty (spam trap):
Name
Link
Subject
Comment
File
Password (for post and file deletion)

File: Motto_Hanjuku_Joshi_ch9.png -(1535780 B, 2220x3106) Thumbnail displayed, click image for full size.
1535780 No.24453  

RAW: http://www.mediafire.com/file/tk4szmhv33kuv5o

>> No.24471  

I will start cleaning in anticipation that Multiball will be translating again.

>> No.24485  

>>24471

Confirmed, that's the plan.

>> No.24542  
File: motto_ch9.txt -(9532 B, 0x0) Thumbnail displayed, click image for full size.

>>24471
>>24485

Plan enacted.

>> No.24593  
>[9/16 (33_1.png)]
>あーあ負けちゃった
>Aw, man, I lose!

Should that be "lost"?

>> No.24594  
>[10/16 (34_1.png)]
>世界で人気なのはエペ
>Épée is the popular one worldwide.

Maybe "Épée is most popular worldwide? Just sounds kinda strange as it is to me.

>> No.24595  
>なんのはなし!?
>What are you talking about‽
>学校の中だってば
>We're still at school!

Would this be "still in school"? That is to say, the interpretation is that they only do kissing because they are still young. They look like they are in a fast food place, not at school, which is how I would interpret it as translated.

>> No.24601  

>>24593

I think either one is acceptable here. given that the masks are only just coming off, and the match has just ended, either "I lose" or "I lost" are appropriate in English. In Japanese, you would use 負けちゃった for either usage in English. I don't think it has to change.

>>24594

Yeah, this one was a little weird. I left it a bit awkward in English because it seemed a bit awkward to me in Japanese. If my Japanese were better, maybe I would have encountered this formulation before, and it wouldn't have seemed as awkward. The strange thing to me is that there wasn't an 一番 or anything in the original. 一番 is so common in Japanese that it seemed strange not to see one here, and it seemed like the best way to translate that strangeness was to leave out a "most." The "<adjectivbe>の" or "<adjecting>なの" structure is commonly translated "<adjective> one," so this seemed like the best representation of the original to me. I'm welcome to improvements, but I would sort of like to make sure to omit the word "most."

>>24595

This one was add to me, too. Ayumi is clearly implying, "We don't do more than kiss" because they're still on school grounds. As far as I can tell, 学校の中 is pretty unambiguous in that part: it's about being physically at or in a school building or campus. If Ayumi had been talking about waiting until they were older, I would have expected a different term than 学校, something like 学生 or 未成年; I don't know of a Japanese expression equivalent to the English "in school" that's commonly used to mean "attending a school," with the common implication "therefore a dependent or still immature." To say something like "still in school," I would expect a phrase like まだ学生です or 卒業まだしていない; more literally, you might say something like 学校に通っています, though my first impression on reading that would probably be that the person in question is on their way to or from school at this moment.

But you're still right that it's an awkward thing for Ayumi to say at this point in the comic, and it doesn't get the point across as well as I'd like it to. I feel like in actual conversation, people would use a historical present, but that still wouldn't work well in person, and it works even worse in text. Maybe something like

>なんのはなし!?
>What are you talking about‽
>学校の中だってば
>Not when we're at school!
>> No.24604  

>>24601
Here's an explanation of the のは pattern
https://itazuraneko.neocities.org/grammar/dojg/dojgpages/basic%E3%81%AE%E3%81%AF%E3%81%A0.html

Also, は can be used to contrast different things, which is probably the case here, implying that worldwide the epee is popular, but locally something else is.

That said, I don't have an issue with the original translation. I just wanted to help clear that up since you said it seemed weird.

>> No.24608  

>>24601
>>24604

I think your translation of that Epee line is fine. The original gives more of a feeling of "As for what's popular worldwide, that would be Epee" not "Epee is most popular worldwide." They might mean the same thing, but there's a little bit of difference in emphasis. I think "Épée is the popular one worldwide" captures that perfectly.

>> No.24616  

>>24601
>>24608
Thanks for the explanations. I will keep them all as they were originally translated.

>> No.24620  

Here is the first revision. Please review it.
https://files.catbox.moe/e5mtwv.zip

>> No.24624  
File: motto_9qc1.txt -(5249 B, 0x0) Thumbnail displayed, click image for full size.

>>24620

Here's a review.

Sometimes, I think it'll be all atmospheric and cool to leave off periods in floating text monologues, but it always just feels weird and incomplete to me when I do see it on the page. I've marked where they should be added in.

Besides that, there are comments on a number of things.



Delete Post []
Password